In the forex margin trading, it makes you possible to trade with the narrower spread just like the interbank market. This is much attractive. The forex margin trading does not require any credit line because the margin is placed in advance as collateral. This is how most investors could escape any default against the huge losses. Such narrow spread like 5 or 10 points would make you possible to trade as easily as lower rating banks. The key point of the forex margin trading is to trade forex in the equal condition with the interbank players.
Tuesday, October 13, 2009
Spread in the interbank market
At the interbank market, some market makers are called as price quoters who are obliged to make price quotations both for the bid rate and the offered rate at the same time, and other are called as position takers who take or hit the market prices which the market makers provide for. According to the request by a position taker, the market maker has to show his own price with considering the current market level and his own position. There does not exist the sole price because the forex market is different from the exchange traded products. He price is always moving, and therefore, the market makers would become necessary to quote the market prices with some spread widening as taking risks into consideration.
In the interbank convention, each bank sets a credit line to take the relevant counterparty risk. Each bank sets up the maximum limit of the outstanding, and then, there occurs "Never trade with such a bank". Most banks set the credit line in accordance with the rating or grades. It makes difficult for the lower rating banks to get the credit line from the higher rating banks. Even if the lower rating banks could get the credit line from the higher, the spread they actually trade would become wider. It is not simple how to decide the credit line for each bank because it is closely relating to the annual revenue target. In the forex market, the spread is getting two points or three between good names, while 5 to 10 points between the lower rating banks. It is needless to say that the spread should become wider when the price moving gets more rapidly.
Let's compare to TTS/TTS rates banks offering
Spread on the forex margin trading
Swap point is neutral
Swap poin
Swap trade adjusts the trading price arising from the differential in interest rates. Looking at the trade of long position in USD-JPY as we have mentioned above, and the cost of the position is decreasing day by day. It means a little advantageous for players whi have USD-JPY long position because the price they got originally becomes lower. This is caused by the swap trade for rolling over at the end of the day, and as a result, the trading price is adjusted, which is arising from the interest rate earning between US dollar and Japanese Yen.
To say exactly, the old position is set off by one side of the swap trade and the new one is set up by another side of the swap trade with taking the carrying cost into account. The swap trade itself yields nothing. Roughly saying, the higher yield currency is decreasing its values with passage of time. Even if you get some swap points in favor, the value would be going down in the forex market. Adversely, the interest rate might be going down when the value of higher yield foreign currencies is going up.
Swap
The rolling over day by day should be proceeded using swap, which is the combination of buying contract and selling at the same time on the different value dates. The swap is essentially traded for the foreign currency funding. Let us assunme 1 million US dollar versus Japanese Yen which to be bought and sold.
(1) Buying USD and selling JPY on the spot date, which is two business days succeeding to the trade date.
(2) Selling USD and buying JPY on one month correspondent to the spot date
You have to pay JPY and receive USD at the spot date that is two business days after the trade date. Thus, first, your aim to raise fund in USD results in achievement. After one month passes, the value date of (2) comes, you would have to pay the relevant USD and receive JPY. In this way, it follows that you should raise the fund in USD using the collateral in JPY during that period. Stop here a bit. In case that the interest rate of JPY is assumed to be 1% and that of USD to be 6%, it should be a bad trade for the USD lender for that one month, isn't it? Therefore, the swap trade has the market convention that the trading price should be adjusted in advance not to be disadvantage for the side who is placing higher yield foreign currency. This price gap is just called as the swap point arising from the differential of interest rates yielding between two currencies. In case that the commodity currency yields higher interest than the base currency, it follows to be called as discount system. One the other hand, in case that the commodity yields lower, it should be as premium system. It is needless to say that there does not exist any exchange risk because the trade of buying and selling would be made at the same time.
It does not make sense that the swap is traded itself. The banks use the swap trade for covering the foreign currency deficit during the necessary period. In the forex margin trading, the swap trade is made use of for the position rolling over day by day. If you buy US dollar in the forex market, you would need to pay JPY two business day succeeding to the trade date, but you can postpone the payment schedule using the swap trade. When your position becomes sure to leave open at the end of the day, you have to take action to avoid JPY payment on the following day. You have to make a swap trade that forces you buying JPY and selling USD on the original payment date and selling JPY and buying USD freshly with some swap points on the following day of the original payment date. Most forex brokers usually make this swap trade automatically without customers' permission. In addition, this swap trade cost no commission fee. In this way, individual investors can carry their position for ever. As the swap trade is defined as a purchasing agreement and not a loan agreement, the forex margin trading allows investors to raise fund at on-balance without any loan agreement.
Rolling over
Forex margin trading and Swap
Attractive commission fees
Narrower width to the cost and the higher chance
The price movement of 10 points brings about 10,000 JPY on the profit or loss if the trading position is 0.1 million USD-JPY. In the same way, the one point difference in the width to the cost should have got one thousand JPY, and it will affect to the investors psychologically whether the commission fees could be fully covered or not. When your position gets in favor, you will encounter the break even point where your are free from any trading cost. This is just the first significant phase you may face after taking position. You will feel easy when the market goes beyond this break even point.
The most important thing starts from here. If you feel the market movement is somehow strange, you must be annoyed where to exit or cut your position safely just after taking position. Sound judgment and immediate action are indispensable to withdrawal from the forex market. It is possible to get out easily without damage if the commission fees have already been covered up. As you can see, the narrower width to the cost would make you easier to get out of the forex market. As is often the case, some beginners are seen to fail into the depth to hell because they cannot take the relevant action to cut their position when needed.
The round trip commission fees
Width to the cost
Market risk is regardless of leverage
The market risk is dependent on the volume you trade, which is regardless of the leverage ratio. It depends on your choice whether you would have intention to trade the biggest position you are allowed to take. Higher leverage is often said to be more risky than the lower one, but you should understand the higher leverage allow you to some more rooms to decide the size of your position by yourself, which is quite advantageous for all investors because the amount of trading might become bigger using the same margin like the mortgage loan based on the collateral value.
The leverage is attractive
The forex margin trading has the great characteristics, so this is the high leverage. Assume that the mortgage loan when to borrow money from the bank. You can borrow some money within the collateral value of your land. If your collateral is worth about ten million Yen, it makes you possible to raise the fund up to 10 million JPY. If there is no need to raise, you have only to borrow money you need for the present, and it indicates there is more room to raise fund by borrowing money up to remaining 9 million JPY when you feel like.
The leverage mentions to the biggest possible amount of your position carrying in the forex margin trading. It shows how much times the margin allow you to trade. The margin requirement is indicated how much money you are required in advance to trade for each currency pairs, like USD-JPY, EUR-USD, GBP-USD. For example, 2,000 or 5,000 USD would be required for trade per 0.1 million USD. The smaller margin requirement follows the higher leverage ratio, needless to say.
What is the leverage effect?
Maintenance margin
Margin requirement
Margin
We usually pay some money just to buy something. In the same way, the forex market is defined to make a process to settle two days in arrear to the trade date. This is so called OTC spot trading. On the other hand, we don't have to pay full amount in the forex margin trading and we are required to pay or receive the translation gains or losses when the position are made square. Here, a problem may happen. If the losses by a certain investor expand further and he got fallen default to pay any more, what is happening? Such trading system would be forced to fail to keep working.
The margin requirement is defined as the deposit necessary for some collateral in order to solve such kind of problem. The forex margin trading turns out to be very efficient in the fund usage, and the forex margin trading requires one of tenth or one of twentieth as much money as the actual face value you would try to trade, although you might feel strange.
The name of margin which means "proof" in Japanese, should come from where investors must show money as proof to keep trading in former days. There are various types of the margin, the initial margin, the margin requirement and the maintenance margin. The beginner might feel unfamiliar to those terminologies.
Difference between forex margin trading and commodity futures
He forex margin trading is fully equipped with automatic loss cut system, which is quite different from the margin call system in the Commodity futures practice. Additional margin would be claimed when the losses by the Commodity futures expands to some extent. It is an awful system because you should always meet the margin requirement and fill the shortage in the margin account, which is usually required when the revaluation loss reaches 50% of the margin requirement.
In the forex margin trading, most brokers adopt the automatic loss cut system, where you would be forced to cut all your position to avoid further losses. This system functions as a safety net for individual investors, and the brokers using this system won't claim any additional margin even if the account balance falls deficit.
The forex margin trading does not have the delivery month to settle off while the Commodity futures have. The Commodity futures have some delivery months in line with the last trading date, like March, June, September and December. On the other hand, the forex margin trading has no maturity date, and so, the position in the forex margin trading is automatically rolled over until liquidation. It could be carried over without any limit until the liquidation, so long as the account balance allows. You have to roll over the futures contract if you carry it toward the next delivery month, while you don't have to mind in the forex margin trading.
Initial margin and the inception requirement
Commodity futures
Commodity futures market
According to the market convention in Japan, the Commodity futures is priced using both one-board trade and price-matching. Looking at the Tokyo Commodity Exchange, for example, the rubber futures are traded in the pit session by some men, while the crude lights or gold futures are traded in the electric session by computers. In case of one-board trade, it would be executed at the routine hours like the opening hour or the closing hour, where the prices on all demand are centralized toward the sole price.
Help desk for beginners
Comparison in the leverage
Comparison in the online system
The point to choose a forex broker with online trade depends on the system platform. Most forex brokers can provide for the demo style trading. First, you have to experience how to easy to use the platform on the demo version, and second, you would find how long to take for making the forex trades and how fair the price quotation is. Finally, you have to compare various platforms to pick up. Pay attention to the price quotation again when to trade in the real time market. In actual, some forex brokers would intentionally slide their price quotation in the direction disadvantageous for the customers, when they could judge the direction of customers' interest. It should be better to withdraw your money from such forex brokers as lead customers to the unhappy road, if you feel uneasy after several trials.
More attention to be needed that there are some other forex brokers who don't prepare the demo style platform. Even if the copy to catch is wonderful, you should not follow such forex brokers as have only the poor equipment. It is most significant to all the investors where the forex brokers can offer the fair price quotation on the real time basis. In addition, this is another key point to capture your own profit or loss on real time basis. It is most important for the platform system whether to be easy to use or not. Let's make sure of it using the demo style trading.
Comparison in the spread
Troubles increasing
The forex margin trading is a very speculative financial product. The leverage would affect equally to both profit and loss. It is suitable only for the investors who expect higher returns against higher risks. Investors should not make use of the money necessary for the daily life.
It is a fact that a number of forex brokers are increasing who explains in the wrong way, "it is just similar to the foreign currency deposit", "it is sure to take profit" or "the swap points between two foreign currencies should yield several times as much as lower coupon". Never be cheated by such sales talks. Doubt such forex brokers as would cheat you.
Here, we are going to show you how to distinguish bad forex brokers.
- Brokers to cheat the customers with sales talk, "You must get much money" as offering definitive judgment.
- Brokers not to explain enough for the customers to comprehend the risks and characteristics.
- Brokers with so much aggressive attitude.
Example of easy misunderstandings
To avoid useless misunderstandings, let us pick up some words to be taken care of from the "Code of Conduct" for the interbank traders. This booklet explains in Japanese. If you have any interest, take a look at this one.
Anyway, take care of sneezing in front of the mike, please!
From my experience
By the influence of sound quality or other noises, the conversation sometimes becomes hard to hear over the phone. It may bring about unexpected misunderstanding. It often occurs from my own experience when I was a bank staff.
It was the time when I entered the dealing room and tried to say "Good morning" to the forex broker via mike one morning. It was so cold that it might tickle my noise. I sneezed toward the mike. Next moment, a big voice was surrounding, "Given" from the speaker. The colleague traders were just laughing. I asked the forex brokers what has happened because I did not know at all. They said "three million US dollar has been sold". I decided hold that position. Because I felt sad and funny, I asked another friend. He said that he also sold US dollar as well in the morning because of his sneezing. Then, we both could not help bursting out for a while. This was a interesting story that we started from the short position on that day, and it indicates a terrible story that sneezing sound hears like "Hit your three" regardless of our intention.
Cautions on phone trade
Good point of phone trade
The good point of the phone trade is to get some useful information over the conversation. The forex brokers make so much chats in the forex market with many customers where the market information is gathering. They also have special news sources. It is very convenient for investors who have no source to make sure what has happened in the forex market when the market prices move suddenly and rapidly.
The system failure or the connection trouble does not occur in the phone trade. The merit of the phone trade is that it should be stable to trade forex during 24 hours long.
Weak point of phone trade
The weak point of phone trade is just that you cannot trade forex timely and speedy. Several seconds would need for dialing up and another seconds for identifying what the customer to be, and more for specifying the product, the amount and the side you want to trade through the forex broker. In addition, some more seconds would take for getting the price quotation from the forex broker. It might take at least 30 seconds even at the good forex broker who is good at market connection. Usually, it should take above one minute to trade forex in the phone trade.
As the investors who have once experienced the phone trade should know, they could not buy or sell at the market where they have thought to be, and sometimes the price is apt to move in the disadvantageous direction for the investors. This case happens quite often when the investors want to close their positions. The forex brokers would look over their intention to trade, buy or sell, and slide the price quotation upper or lower because the forex brokers should have known the customers' interest in advance. That is because the forex brokers sometimes aim to gain from the gap between the actual market price and the customers' interest. It never happens in the online trade where to show the market price quite fair.
Good point in online trade
The online trade gives us a wonderful chance to trade forex. We can there trade forex promptly with watching the real time market. Nobody wants to miss the chance and the timing to trade forex in line with the actual market. The online trade could satisfy such demand more easily and cheaply.
In phone trade, it will take five seconds to dial up, 10 seconds to identify and 10 or 15 seconds to get the market price. It would take at least 30 seconds even at the brokers who are good at market connection. You would lose the chance to trade forex by 30 seconds, even though you have a good idea in the forex market.
The online trade provides the same market price for all individual investors at the same time, where is regardless of their intention to sell or buy. It follows that all the customers can stand on the fair place in the forex market. This environment is very favorable for the individual investors.
Comparison of system
There are many forex brokers who have various systems for online trade. One needs to install a stand alone software in advance to start trading and another differs in process to start. There are various types and shows respective performance. It is often the case that you cannot start online trade on your PC due to the memory shortage or the mismatching of OS version. It is best to choose the most suitable one to you from a customer-oriented and safety-conscious viewpoint, with taking a look at the demo trade play.
Weak point in online trade
How beneficial the internet tool has been to us! In addition to getting information easily, we take various benefits from the online trades as well. The online trade makes our trading style very simple and smart, but we are face to the risk to pay bigger sacrifice when the system trouble occurs in the network.
The interbank market is fully equipped with some electric broking systems through special devices or terminal for communication, while the forex margin trading for individual investors is executed on a PC basis through the internet. Therefore, the forex margin trading cannot be stable in the environment under which it is not always steady in compared with the interbank market. Failure in PC function, ISP, the provider and the server, various troubles may happen. It is impossible to avoid these factors completely.
All individual investors to use internet service are required to take these demerits into consideration, and to take the relevant actions when the system troubles happen.
Warning
Trading risk
Automatic stop loss and Margin call
Unlike the forex market, the margin call system is adopted to the exchange traded markets, like commodity futures. The broker claims to investors for the additional payment for the compensation of the current revaluation losses in order to maintain the present position outstanding. For example, if the revaluation losses exceed 50% of the margin requirement, the investors have to fill the deficit within some days the broker would call on, otherwise, his position would be made clear at the market price compulsorily.
The forex market is moving during 24 hours without rest. In addition, there is no price band limit to be set in the forex market. The automatic loss cut system is called as the last resort for individual investors to protect from the unexpected market risks.
Difference between forex margin trading and stock trading
What is stock trading?
OTC and Exchange traded
Stock exchange
The stock exchange is established in order to centralize whole market interests at one place for fair trading. There are five stock exchange in Japan and the listed companies' stocks are traded actively there every day. The companies who want to list in the exchange must apply for it and it would win the place to trade in the exchange after passing strict examinations.
Difference between forex margin trading and foreign currency deposit
The forex rates keep moving although 24 hours long, but the most forex authorized banks usually set the fixing rates only once a day. Foreign currency deposit is unsuitable to the short term trading although some banks seem to decide the fixing rates every hour. The forex margin trading just costs about 10 points or 20 points as per side for US dollar, which is quite contrary that the foreign currency deposit does above 200 points on the round trip basis. As a result, the forex margin trading makes you enable to trade forex about 80 percent cheaper than the foreign currency deposit if you have intention to get revaluation gains from it. This fact means that the forex margin trading is regarded as quite day trade oriented even if the market movement is less than expected.
The bank myth that the bigger bank never be collapsed does not go through nowadays, as many banks hold enormously huge amount of bad loans. Assuming the case of bankruptcy, you could lose several money in the forex margin trading, while you would lose all the money in the foreign currency deposit.
Foreign currency deposit away from insurance
Let's compare to other investment
Charm point of forex margin trading
To tell the truth, there is no other investment entities than the forex margin trading from an efficiency viewpoint. The higher leverage and the cheaper commission fees should be very attractive to the individual investors. Some brokers are preparing for the automatic loss cut system for the sake of customers' safety to avoid unexpected loss expansion any more.
This web site is aiming that you should all understand some basic structures and the risks on the forex margin trading. Although some difficult specifications which to be unfamiliar to you, like leverage effect, swap spread and the width to the cost, commission fees or so, you can go ahead to read any section in which you got interested. Please inquire yourself to the forex brokers where you want to start about the margin account because the details of handling the margin account are somehow different from each other. Here, let me allow to explain a rough mechanism of the margin account.
Trading without margin
Later when you sell off your Japanese Yen in higher price (USD/JPY 109.0), the returns you are getting back is $1001.8.
Profit made in the trade: $1.8
ROI of the trade: 1.8/1000 x 100% = 0.18%
Trading with margin
Buying Japanese Yen when USD/JPY 109.2:
Long Japanese Yen = (100 x 1000 x 109.2) Yens = 10,920,000 Yens;
Short USD $100,000.Selling of Japanese Yen when USD/JPY 109.0:
Short Japanese Yen = 10,920,000; Long USD = (10,920,000 / 109) = $100,183.5.
Profit made in the trade: $183.5.
ROI of the trade: 183.5/1000 x 100% = 18.35%
Margin Trades and ROI in Forex
Taking $1,000 in a 100:1 margin account as example, you are now granted the purchase power of $100,000.
Say that you execute the trade between USD/JPY: Long Japanese Yen in USD/JPY 109.2 (meaning buying 109.2 Yens with 1 USD) and short JPY at the price of USD/JPY 109.0.
Leveraging your money in Forex margin trades
It is common to find Forex brokerage firms offering up to a ratio of 1:100 for an account holder. In contrast, in the equity market, a trader needs to come with 50% of the transaction value for every trade that they make. Leveraging is all about profit maximization as well as risk minimization.
With leverage, the Forex trader is able to profit more with each trade that he makes. At the same time, the risk factor of his transaction is also multiplied many times over and hence the need for proper risk management. Margin trading refers to the leverage amount given to the traders to trade in the market.
One of the best features in Forex trading is that traders are able to trade foreign currencies with high margin.
You get 1:1 margin for stock exchanges, 2:1 margin for equity trading, 15:1 margin for futures market; but in Forex, normal trade margins are 100:1 and 150:1, or even 200:1 trade margins.
Typically the broker will require a minimum account size, also known as account margin or initial margin. Once you have deposited your money you will then be able to trade. The broker will also specify how much they require per position (lot) traded.
For example, for every $1,000 you have, you can trade 1 lot of $100,000. So if you have $5,000 they may allow you to trade up to $500,000 of Forex.
The minimum security (margin) for each lot will vary from broker to broker. In the example above, the broker required a one percent margin. This means that for every $100,000 traded, the broker wants $1,000 as a deposit on the position.
Trading Forex in huge margin with allows traders to control a large sum of money with little cash put on the tables. This in turns magnify the ROI dramatically.